The Observer is a Student-run, daily print & online newspaper serving Notre Dame & Saint Mary's. Learn more about us.



Saint Mary’s hosts screening of ‘The Hunting Ground’

| Friday, April 10, 2015

The Belles Against Violence Office (BAVO) sponsored a showing of and panel discussion on the CNN documentary “The Hunting Ground” on Thursday evening in O’Laughlin Auditorium on Saint Mary’s campus.

Saint Mary’s College President Carol Ann Mooney introduced the film, which deals with sexual assaults on college campuses including Saint Mary’s and Notre Dame.

“The film promotes action and an important message and voices that need to be heard,” Mooney said. “I am very proud that two Saint Mary’s women and a Saint Mary’s father were willing to be featured.”

HuntingGrounds_Info_WEBErin Rice | The Observer

In addition to Saint Mary’s and Notre Dame, several other schools were also featured in the documentary, including University of Southern California, Harvard, Dartmouth, North Carolina and Yale, among others.

Lt. Pat Cottrell, a retired official of Notre Dame Security Police (NDSP), was featured in the documentary to talk about sexual assaults on Notre Dame’s campus specifically.

Cottrell said NDSP preferred to keep its crime statistics as low as possible.

Cottrell said this problem was magnified as his bosses would say they had empathy for victims of crimes but did not really support them. Additionally, Cottrell said NDSP could not contact any athlete or athletic staff directly, regarding of any accusation, without first going through University officials.

Paul Browne, vice president for public affairs and communications for the University, said Cottrell’s assertion was false.

“‘The Hunting Ground’ … was wrong in unsupported and inaccurate assertions that the University sought to suppress crime statistics and shield athletes from investigators,” he said in a statement.

Rachel Hudak, a former Saint Mary’s student, was featured in the documentary regarding a sexual assault that allegedly happened on Notre Dame’s campus. Hudak said Mooney disregarded her sexual assault complaint in a meeting.

Tom Seeberg, father of Lizzy Seeberg, a former Saint Mary’s student who committed suicide after an alleged sexual assault by a Notre Dame football player, spoke on his daughter’s behalf.

Seeberg said Lizzy reported the alleged assault the day after it happened and received a threatening text from another football player.

Mooney spoke after the film and said students may wonder why she did not agree to be interviewed by CNN for the movie.

“I hope you know that student privacy is of the utmost importance,” Mooney said. “You may also be wondering about Rachel’s comment, and I remember our conversation very differently than she does. It is through her pain that she remembers. I am, and was then, very sorry I cannot take her pain away.”

Response to the film

Five panelists spoke after the documentary, including Karen Johnson, vice president of Student Affairs at the College, Connie Adams, director of BAVO, Stacy Davis, chair of the Gender and Women’s Studies department, senior Payton Moore and Brian Young, commander of the St. Joseph County Special Victims Unit.

Adams said two key areas stand out most to her after watching the documentary. The first area, she said, was the theme of survivors that feel alone.

“We as a community can respond in a compassionate way,” Adams said.

The second theme in the film is activism, she said.

“They are so many ways we can take on this issue,” Adams said. “We can really assume that call to action.”

Davis said there was a horrible repetitiveness in the documentary of schools covering up sexual assaults.

“My first response was anger,” Davis said. “Then I realized you all have an incredible opportunity because all schools want to get paid and stay open. It was a good thing that [the documentary] shamed schools, so that you [students] are treated fairly.”

Reporting sexual assault

Johnson said the number of reported campus assaults depends on where the assault is reported. She said there are between four to six reports of sexual assaults annually that come across her desk in Student Affairs.

“If they report at Notre Dame, our office doesn’t get that information,” Johnson said. “It’s really important to know that we work with the Title IX coordinator at Notre Dame, and that’s as far as we can work with them. What we do here is to provide as much support regardless of where they were assaulted. Things can change if we all work together to make that happen.”

Adams said it is important to listen to the student’s needs through the healing process.

“When we’re talking about violence, we’re talking about taking power away,” Adams said. “The support has to be about getting that power back, and the support we have on campus is to empower the students.”

As an alumna of Saint Mary’s, Adams said she has seen growth returning to the campus as the director of BAVO. The office began in the spring of 2010, and it has continued to evolve and grow since then, especially in regards to student activism, she said.

Young said he was struck by the lack of compassion on the part of law enforcement in the documentary. He said St. Joseph County SVU will work with a student as soon as an incident is reported to the department.

“We work with the victim and want to be considerate to what has happened and certainly compassionate towards what she’s going through,” Young said.

Johnson said she also works closely the Title IX coordinator at Notre Dame.

“We can’t dictate to Notre Dame what the outcome of a case should be, but we can only support our students. The hard part for all of us is that we are two separate legal entities, and therefore the best I can do is meeting and going through the processes,” she said.

The panel concluded without answering all audience questions. Moderator Frances Kominkiwicz said all questions submitted by members of the audience will be answered in a written document on the BAVO webpage and sent out in an email.

Tags: , , , , ,

About Haleigh Ehmsen

A senior at Saint Mary's, Haleigh is majoring in Communication Studies and English Literature & Writing. She serves as the Saint Mary's editor and enjoys coffee, guacamole and good books.

Contact Haleigh
  • Tom Seeberg

    Lizzy received world-class support from BAVO and Connie Adams at Saint Mary’s after her she was assaulted. Carol Mooney, Karen Johnson and other SMC admin. have always shown genuine care and concern for our family which we greatly appreciate. SMC ladies – you are fortunate to be part of such a loving and supportive community. Once a Belle, always a Belle!

    Mary & Tom Seeberg

    • Annette Magjuka

      Mr. Seeberg, you were very brave to appear in this important film. My husband and I saw it this weekend. We are both ND grads. I graduated in ’78. I remember when your daughter tragically took her life. I read everything I could about this at the time. I remember reading that both she and the accused were reported to give similar statements about the encounter–that she took off her shirt, he touched her breast, she said stop, and he did. In the movie, you told a totally different version. Are you saying that the “statements” in the news were not correct? I am horrified at the lack of support victims of sexual assault receive across all universities. I know that ND has a problem just like all other universities. ND does not have frats, and frats are implicated in the documentary. I want ND to be a leader on this issue. I am so very sorry about your loss. The loss of your precious daughter is a loss for the entire SMC/ND community. It makes me happy that you were supported at SMC. This film was relevant for our family since two of our kids went to ND and one went to UNC!

      • Tom Seeberg

        Annette – thank you for your kind words. Yes, whatever “statements” you are referring to in the press or elsewhere do NOT accurately reflect what Lizzy asserted in her complaint. The (simple) “touching of her breasts” came from (then) St. Joe County Prosecutor, Michael Dvorak, in his extraordinary and misleading “no charges” press release of December 16, 2010 when describing what Lizzy alleged as sexual battery. The statement was a big gift to Prince Shembo and ND’s PR machine that allowed them to sell their “date-gone-wrong
        troubled girl freaks out when boy touches her breast” narrative.

        Lizzy’s statement indicates that she was surprised and uneasy when the other two students left the room (abruptly) and alleges that once they were alone, 6’2″ 260 lb. linebacker Shembo, basically jumped her. She describes a terrifying assault that began with the forceful removal of her shirt and bra and an attempt to
        remove her pants and ended when he abruptly threw her to the side, expressing
        that he “I could get kicked off the football team for this”. Lizzy describes being forcibly held down and attacked. Dvorak’s deliberate and sickening misrepresentation of the events was a huge gift to ND and even bigger disservice to Lizzy’s reputation.

        Whatever you or anyone else believes happened in that dorm room, the issue for us was never Shembo’s guilt or innocence, or about holding anyone responsible for Lizzy’s death. The sole issue of our focus was that NDSP conducted in an intentionally superficial investigation into Lizzy’s complaint and let potentially key evidence (electronic communication) spoil. We wanted to make sure that the same thing wouldn’t happen to the next woman who lodges a similar complaint. We are pleased that our efforts to demand Lizzy’s voice be heard, led to ND’s 2011 settlement agreement with the Department of Education to make changes to it’s sexual assault response process.

        If you would like more detail on Lizzy’s statement and allegations, please see this story for an accurate accounting of the facts in her case: http://ncronline.org/news/accountability/reported-sexual-assault-notre-dame-campus-leaves-more-questions-answers
        Thank you again for your kinds words and interest in clarifying the facts here.

        • Annette Magjuka

          I am so angry that the police/security, university officials collude to deny any appropriate recourse for sexual abuse victims. ND markets itself as “a family” and in many ways it is. But on this issue, the university has betrayed the trust of our young people and those who love them. I thank you for you painful yet powerful testimony. It has already helped to change some policy. We need even more aware

          • Annette Magjuka

            awareness and positive action